Islanders Eliminated: Playoff Hopes Dashed in Loss to Canadiens
The Islanders' playoff hopes officially ended with a 4-1 loss to Montreal. Breaking down what went wrong and what it means for futures bettors.
Islanders Eliminated: Playoff Hopes Dashed in Loss to Canadiens
The New York Islanders’ season is officially over—at least the part that matters. A 4-1 loss to Montreal on Sunday mathematically eliminated the Isles from playoff contention, capping a brutal 1-6 stretch that turned what looked like a wild card lock into a familiar late-season collapse. For anyone still holding Islanders futures tickets, this is the ‘let it slip away’ moment Casey Cizikas described postgame. The Isles were in a good spot. They burned it. If you rode the under on their season point total or faded them ATS down the stretch, you got paid.
Market Overview: Where the Islanders Went Wrong
This wasn’t a team that limped into April already dead. The Islanders had playoff positioning as recently as three weeks ago. But books adjusted quickly once the losing started. By mid-March, their playoff odds had cratered from around +150 to make the postseason to well north of +400. Sharp money moved off them early. The public held on longer, hoping a coaching change from Patrick Roy to Pete DeBoer would spark something. It didn’t. DeBoer is 1-2 since taking over, and the season finale against Carolina on Tuesday is now meaningless except for draft lottery positioning.
Montreal, meanwhile, is pushing for home-ice advantage in Round 1 and a potential Atlantic Division title. The Canadiens closed as roughly -180 favorites Sunday—a line that never looked in doubt after they buried three goals in 55 seconds late in the second period.
Odds Block
No live betting odds are available for this completed game. For current NHL futures and upcoming matchups, check the bet105 NHL odds page.
Key Factors: Anatomy of a Collapse
1. The Islanders Couldn’t Score When It Mattered
DeBoer’s postgame quote tells the whole story: “It’s hard to win in this league with one goal.” New York generated chances but converted almost nothing over their final seven games. This wasn’t a Sorokin problem—he stopped 18 of 22 shots Sunday and has been the only reason games were competitive. The issue is a roster that lacks finishing talent at the top. When you need goals, Cizikas redirects aren’t enough.
2. Special Teams Buried Them
Montreal’s second goal came on the power play. Ivan Demidov finished a one-timer off a Nick Suzuki feed, and that was the game. The Islanders’ penalty kill has been league-average, but average doesn’t cut it against a Montreal power play clicking at over 25% in April. Sharp bettors fading the Isles identified this mismatch weeks ago.
3. The Coaching Change Came Too Late
Firing Patrick Roy and bringing in DeBoer with three games left is a desperation move, not a strategy. DeBoer had no time to implement systems or build trust. The players were already mentally checked out. Books didn’t move the line significantly after the coaching news—they knew it was theater.
Sharp Angle: Montreal Futures Value Remains
The real story here is Montreal. Nick Suzuki hitting 100 points for the first time in his career signals a team peaking at the right time. He’s got 29 goals and 72 assists with games still to play. Lane Hutson added three assists from the blue line. Jacob Fowler stopped 30 shots and looked like a goalie capable of stealing a playoff series.
If you’re looking for value, the Canadiens’ Stanley Cup futures have shortened but may still offer edge depending on their Round 1 matchup. Home-ice advantage in the Atlantic is within reach. A team this hot, with a goalie playing this well, is dangerous. The Islanders were simply collateral damage on Montreal’s playoff push.
What This Means for Bettors
The Islanders close their season Tuesday against Carolina. Expect the Hurricanes to be heavy favorites—likely in the -200 range or steeper. Carolina is playing for seeding; New York is playing for nothing. If you’re looking to bet this game, the lean is Carolina puck line or the under, assuming both teams coast through a meaningless finale with backups getting run.
For futures bettors, the Islanders’ elimination is just math catching up to reality. This roster needed a top-six upgrade at the deadline and didn’t get one. The goaltending was good enough. The structure was acceptable. They just couldn’t finish. Same story, different year.
Frequently Asked Questions
When were the Islanders eliminated from the 2026 playoffs?
The New York Islanders were officially eliminated from 2026 playoff contention on April 12, 2026, following a 4-1 loss to the Montreal Canadiens at UBS Arena in Elmont, NY.
What is the Islanders’ record under Pete DeBoer?
Pete DeBoer is 1-2 since replacing Patrick Roy as Islanders head coach. The coaching change came with three games remaining in the regular season and did not prevent the team’s elimination.
Did Nick Suzuki reach 100 points in the 2025-26 season?
Yes. Nick Suzuki recorded a goal and an assist against the Islanders on April 12, 2026, pushing him past the 100-point mark for the first time in his NHL career. He finished the game with 29 goals and 72 assists.
